Hunt Club Steakhouse delivers a refined dining experience characterized by premium steaks, fresh seafood, and attentive service. The menu highlights include expertly prepared steaks with customizable seasonings, fresh seafood specialties like crab cakes and lobster pappardelle, and their signature duck fat Parker House rolls. The restaurant maintains the charm of its historic 1915 mansion setting while offering an upscale dining atmosphere that makes it particularly popular for special occasions and anniversary celebrations. Customer reviews consistently praise the combination of sophisticated ambiance, professional service, and high-quality food preparation.
Description generated from Google data and customer reviews
"We spent the day in Lake Geneva shopping and celebrating our anniversary. I wanted to take my wife out for a nice dinner to a good restaurant for our 58th wedding anniversary. I booked reservations at the Hunt Club Steakhouse and after reading the reviews I was a little skeptical after I booked my reservations. We arrived at 5 PM for our reservations. We were seated immediately by a pleasant hostess. Our waiter, William, who goes by “Will I Am” was a fantastic server and waited on us and served us our meal and did a great job. He immediately served us some complementary champagne to celebrate our anniversary. I had the New York strip and I ordered it with salt and pepper seasoning only and well done. It was cooked to perfection and my wife, Mary had the crabcake appitizer and the lobster special. She said both were delicious. Not sure why all of the bad reviews because our meal was excellent and the service was even better. We had a wonderful time and a good meal with a great atmosphere to go with it. I gave William a good tip and would definitely go back again and request William for a waiter. I would highly recommend if you want to go to a first class restaurant for a good meal and excellent service. We definitely will be going back again….👍👍"
"Our experience at Hunt Club Steakhouse was absolutely spectacular! This is a first-class Wisconsin supper club experience beautifully housed in a lovingly curated 1915 building. Our server, William, was a highlight, guiding us through a truly delicious dining experience with authentic care. The wines by the glass offerings were excellent, and the Chef and team presented dishes that were as beautiful to look at as they were delicious to eat. I highly recommend starting with the Duck Fat Parker House Rolls and the Local Apples & Crescenza (and OH! the Wagyu Strip!). The seafood dishes were also spot on—the Lobster Pappardelle was truly the best I've ever had. I'll be telling people about this exceptional meal for quite a while. I hope to be back soon!"
"Out did our expectations! There was not one bad thing that we ordered. The drinks were incredible and generous. We started off with a crab cake, continued with the tenderloin, bone in ribeye, potatatos and Brussels. This food was not hotel fridge worthy, so we felt the need to finish every bite there! Finished off with the cheesecake and it was the perfect meal for our anniversary. We will definitely be going back again. Though pricey, it was worth every penny."
Early evening reservations around 5:00 PM are recommended for the best dining experience and attention to service
Request a table near the fireplace for a more intimate dining experience. Though prices are on the higher end, portions are generous and the steak preparation and seasoning can be customized to preference.
The closest places to eat, things to do and essentials from our Lake Geneva local guide.
Cafe0.2 mi4.8 (100)
Restaurant0.6 mi4.8 (66)
Coffee shop0.7 mi4.7 (419)
Bar0.8 mi4.2 (518)
Pizza restaurant0.9 mi5.0 (2)
Tourist attraction0.7 mi4.7 (392)
Dog park0.7 mi4.7 (3)
Pilates studio0.8 mi5.0 (41)
Beach0.9 mi4.6 (134)
Fishing charter0.9 mi5.0 (9)
Convenience store0.9 mi4.0 (29)
Liquor store0.9 mi4.5 (64)
Grocery store1.0 mi4.5 (119)
Grocery store2.8 mi4.8 (47)
Liquor store4 mi4.5 (4)
Be the first to know about deals, news, and events from this business.

647 W Main St #100

156 Elkhorn Rd

N3241 Co Trunk H

812 Wrigley Dr

1560 N Country Club Pkwy

883 W Main St

220 Cook St

N6419 US-12

W3731 Club House Dr

235 Broad St